Shop › Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheese Image 1 of 1 Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheese from $3.49 Call for Pricing Shullsburg Wisconsin Cheese. A Masterfully Crafted Sharp - Firm yet slice-able. Nutty and Creamy with a sharp note. Amount: Select Amount 1 Pound 3/4 Pound 1/2 Pound 1/4 Pound Call for Pricing Added! Shullsburg Wisconsin Cheese. A Masterfully Crafted Sharp - Firm yet slice-able. Nutty and Creamy with a sharp note.